New York City vs Columbus Crew

MLS - Group Stage 17 Sep 2025, 23:30
New York City
New York City
3–2
HT 1–1
FULL TIME
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
🏟 Yankee Stadium

Match report

New York City edged past Columbus Crew 3-2 in the MLS - Group Stage on 17 September 2025. It was 1-1 at half-time, with 3 more goals in the second half.

New York City had 18 shots to Columbus Crew's 8.

The match was played at Yankee Stadium.

Half-time 1-1 Possession 59% - 41% Shots 18 - 8 On target 8 - 5 Corners 7 - 3 Fouls 10 - 12 Yellow cards 1
8
Player of the match
Hannes Wolf
New York City · 2 goals
8 Julián Fernández 1 goal
8 Dániel Gazdag 1 goal
8 Wessam Abou Ali 1 goal
8 Agustin Ojeda 2 assists
First half vs second half
New York City stepped it up after the break, with 12 shots in the second half compared to 6 in the first.
  1st half 2nd half
Shots Total 6–5 12–3
Shots On Goal 4–4 4–1
Ball Possession 61–39 —
Corners 3–2 4–1
Attacks 47–50 54–52
Match statistics
7 Corners 3
0 Penalty 1
4 Substitution 4
101 Attacks 102
70 Dangerous Attacks 61
9 On Target 3
7 Off Target 3
59% Ball Possession 41%
18 Shots Total 8
8 Shots On Goal 5
4 Shots Off Goal 0
6 Shots Blocked 3
12 Shots Inside Box 8
6 Shots Outside Box 0
10 Fouls 12
7 Corners 3
0 Offsides 2
57% Ball Possession 43%
1 Yellow Cards 0
3 Saves 5
556 Passes Total 430
461 Passes Accurate 341
Line-ups 4-2-3-1  vs  5-3-2
Goalkeeper Defender Midfielder Forward
New York City · 4-2-3-1
49 M. Freese
24 T. Gray 13 T. Martins 80 J. Haak 22 K. O'Toole
8 A. Perea 21 A. O'Neill
7 N. Fernández 10 M. Moralez 17 H. Wolf
16 A. Martínez
Columbus Crew · 5-3-2
28 P. Schulte
2 M. Herrera 31 S. Moreira 21 Y. Cheberko 18 M. Amundsen 27 M. Arfsten
16 T. Habroune 6 D. Nagbe 30 H. Picard
8 D. Gazdag 9 W. Ali
New York City
Coach
Pascal Jansen
Substitutes
  • 26 Agustin Ojeda
  • 11 Julián Fernández
  • 32 Jonathan Shore
  • 99 Seymour Garfield-Reid
  • 30 Tomás Romero
  • 35 Mitja Ilenič
  • 19 Strahinja Tanasijević
  • 34 Raul Gustavo
  • 29 Máximo Carrizo
Columbus Crew
Coach
Wilfried Nancy
Substitutes
  • 48 Cesar Ruvalcaba
  • 7 Dylan Chambost
  • 14 Amar Sejdic
  • 19 Jacen Russell-Rowe
  • 1 Nicholas Hagen
  • 24 Evan Bush
  • 11 Ibrahim Aliyu
  • 20 Derrick Jones
  • 44 Tristan Brown
Substitutions
  • 46' ↑ C. Ruvalcaba ↓ S. Moreira Columbus Crew
  • 67' ↑ J. Fernandez ↓ M. Moralez New York City
  • 67' ↑ A. Ojeda ↓ A. Martinez New York City
  • 71' ↑ D. Chambost ↓ H. Picard Columbus Crew
  • 82' ↑ J. Shore ↓ A. O'Neill New York City
  • 82' ↑ S. Garfield Reid ↓ N. Mercau New York City
  • 83' ↑ A. Sejdic ↓ D. Gazdag Columbus Crew
  • 83' ↑ J. Russell-Rowe ↓ D. Nagbe Columbus Crew
Cards
  • 90+5' J. Fernandez New York City
Head-to-head
New York City 5 3 draws 8 Columbus Crew
2026-05-10 New York City vs Columbus Crew 0 - 0
2025-09-17 New York City vs Columbus Crew 3 - 2
2025-03-23 Columbus Crew vs New York City 0 - 0
2024-08-31 Columbus Crew vs New York City 4 - 2
2024-08-17 Columbus Crew vs New York City 2 - 1
2024-06-14 New York City vs Columbus Crew 2 - 3
Recent form
New York City L D D D D
Columbus Crew L D D D D
Frequently asked questions
What was the final score in New York City vs Columbus Crew?
New York City won 3-2 against Columbus Crew on 17 September 2025.
Who won New York City vs Columbus Crew?
New York City won the match 3-2.
Where was New York City vs Columbus Crew played?
The match was played at Yankee Stadium.
Who had more possession in New York City vs Columbus Crew?
New York City had 59% of possession, compared to 41% for the other side.